TAS - CAS 29 de 2021
Detalles
- Título
- TAS - CAS 29 de 2021
- Autor
- Tribunal de Arbitraje Deportivo
- Categoría
- Jurisprudencia
- Área del derecho
- Deporte
- Año
- 2021
CAS Anti-Doping Division
Chambre Anti-dopage du TAS
Avenue de Rhodanie 60 CH-1007 Lausanne Tel: +41 (21) 613 50 00 antidoping@tas-cas.org Château de Béthusy Av. de Beaumont 2 CH-1012 Lausanne Tel: +41 (21) 613 50 00 Fax: +41 (21) 613 50 01 procedures@tas-cas.org
2021/ADD/29 World Rowing v. Vladislav Ryabtsev 2021/ADD/36 World Rowing v. Denis Kleshnev 2021/ADD/39 World Rowing v. Vyacheslav Mikhaylevskiy 2021/ADD/40 World Rowing v. Sergej Fedorovtsev ARBITRAL AWARD delivered by the
ANTI-DOPING DIVISION
OF THE COURT OF ARBITRATION FOR SPORT
sitting in the following composition:
Sole Arbitrator: Mr Markus Manninen, Attorney-at-law in Helsinki, Finland in the arbitration between World Rowing, Lausanne, Switzerland Represented by Ms Dominique Leroux-Lacroix, Head of Legal Affairs , Ms Ayesha Talpade, Senior Legal Counsel, and Mr Anton Sotir, Senior Legal Counsel, International Testing Agency, Lausanne, Switzerland
Claimant and Mr Vladislav Ryabtsev, Russia Mr Denis Kleshnev, Russia Mr Vyacheslav Mikhaylevskiy, Russia Mr Sergej Fedorovtsev, Russia Represented by Mr Andrea Pinna, Attorney-at-law, Pinna Goldberg, Paris, France
RespondentsCAS Anti-Doping Division Chambre Anti-dopage du TAS 2021/ADD/29 World Rowing v. Vladislav Ryabtsev, 2021/ADD/36 World Rowing v. Denis Kleshnev,
RespondentsCAS Anti-Doping Division Chambre Anti-dopage du TAS 2021/ADD/29 World Rowing v. Vladislav Ryabtsev, 2021/ADD/36 World Rowing v. Denis Kleshnev, 2021/ADD/39 World Rowing v. Vyacheslav Mikhaylevskiy, 2021/ADD/40 World Rowing v. Sergej Fedorovtsev - Page 2
613 50 00 Fax: +41 (21) 613 50 01 procedures@tas-cas.org
I. PARTIES
1. World Rowing (“WR” or the “Claimant”), formerly known as the “Fédération Internationale des Sociétés d’Aviron” (“FISA”) until 2021, is the world governing body for the sport of rowing. As a signatory of the World Anti -Doping Code (the “WADC”), WR has enacted the WR anti-doping rules as amended from time to time. WR has delegated the implementation of the WR anti -doping programme to the International Testing Agency ( the “ITA”, referred to as “WR” when the ITA is acting on behalf of WR ). This delegation includes the results management and subsequent prosecution of potential anti-doping rule violations (“ADRV”) under the jurisdiction of WR. By virtue of this delegation, the ITA acts on behalf of WR in these proceedings.
2. Mr Vladislav Ryabtsev (“Mr Ryabtsev”) is a Russian rower. He has participated in elite rowing competitions since 2008. He is the 2015 winner of the European title in quadruple sculls and a sixtime Russian champion in quadruple sculls. He competed in the Olympic Games in London in 2012 and in Rio De Janeiro in 2016.
3. Mr Denis Kleshnev (“ Mr Kleshnev”) is a Russian rower. He has participated in elite rowing competitions since 2005. He has represented the Russian national team on several international
and in Rio De Janeiro in 2016.
3. Mr Denis Kleshnev (“ Mr Kleshnev”) is a Russian rower. He has participated in elite rowing competitions since 2005. He has represented the Russian national team on several international events, including the World Rowing Championships and the European Rowing Championships. He won the Russian Rowing Championship in quadruple sculls in 2014 and in octuple sculls in 2016.
He became a silver medallist of the Russian Rowing Championship in single sculls in 2012 and 2015 and a bronze medallist in double sculls in 2017 and 2018.
4. Mr Vyacheslav Mikhaylevskiy (“Mr Mikhaylevskiy”) is a Russian rower. He has participat ed in elite rowing competitions since 2007. He won the first place in the 2015 quadruple sculls World Championships and the first place in the 2015 quadruple sculls European Championships.
5. Mr Sergej Fedorovtsev (“Mr Fedorovtsev”) is a Russian rower . He participated in rowing competitions from 1997 to 2016. He won a gold medal in the Olympic Games in Athens in 2004 and competed in the Olympic Games in Beijing in 2008 and in London in 2012.
6. Mr Ryabtsev, Mr Kleshnev, Mr Mikhaylevskiy, and Mr Fedorovtsev are hereinafter jointly referred to as the “Athletes” or the “Respondents” and individually as an “Athlete”. The Claimant and the Respondents are hereinafter referred to as the “Parties” and individually as a “Party”.
II. FACTUAL BACKGROUND
7. Below is a summary of the relevant facts and allegations based on the Parties’ written submissions, pleadings, and evidence adduced in these proceedings. Additional facts and allegations found in the Parties’ written submissions, pleadings, and evidence may be set out, where relevant, in connection
II. FACTUAL BACKGROUND
7. Below is a summary of the relevant facts and allegations based on the Parties’ written submissions, pleadings, and evidence adduced in these proceedings. Additional facts and allegations found in the Parties’ written submissions, pleadings, and evidence may be set out, where relevant, in connection with the legal discussion that follows. While the Sole Arbitrator has considered all the facts, allegations, legal arguments, and evidence submitted by the Parties in the present proceedings, he only refers to the submissions and evidence he considers necessary to explain his reasoning.
8. These proceedings arise from alleged violations under Article 2.2 of the 2009 FISA Anti -Doping Bye-Laws (“2009 ADR”) for use of anabolic androgenic steroids (“AAS”) by the Athletes when preparing for the 2014 World Rowing Championships. The Athletes participated in said competitions held in Amsterdam, the Netherlands, from 24 to 31 August 2014 , where they placed
5th.
9. On 18 June 2014, Mr Ryabtsev, Mr Mikhaylevskiy, and Mr Fedorovtsev were subject to an out-ofcompetition (“OOC”) doping control by the Russian National Anti -Doping Organisation (“RUSADA”) during a training camp. They provided the following urine sample s: 2916655 (MrCAS Anti-Doping Division
Chambre Anti-dopage du TAS 2021/ADD/29 World Rowing v. Vladislav Ryabtsev, 2021/ADD/36 World Rowing v. Denis Kleshnev, 2021/ADD/39 World Rowing v. Vyacheslav Mikhaylevskiy, 2021/ADD/40 World Rowing v. Sergej Fedorovtsev - Page 3
613 50 00 Fax: +41 (21) 613 50 01 procedures@tas-cas.org
2021/ADD/40 World Rowing v. Sergej Fedorovtsev - Page 3
613 50 00 Fax: +41 (21) 613 50 01 procedures@tas-cas.org Ryabtsev), 2916392 (Mr Mikhaylevskiy), and 2920086 (Mr Fedorovtsev). The samples were reported as negative by the W orld Anti-Doping Agency (“WADA”) accredited laboratory of Moscow (the “Moscow Laboratory”).
10. On 18 July 2014, the Athletes were subject to another OOC doping control by RUSADA . They provided the following samples: 2917997 (Mr Ryabtsev), 2916824 ( Mr Kleshnev), 2920168 (Mr Mikhaylevskiy), and 2916364 (Mr Fedorovtsev). The sample s were reported as negative by the
Moscow Laboratory.
11. On 9 August 2014, the Athletes were subject to another OOC doping control by RUSADA. No prohibited substances were detected in the initial testing procedure (“ITP”) of the following samples: 2946802 (Mr Ryabtsev), 2946508 (Mr Kleshnev), 2945822 (Mr Mikhaylevskiy), and 2946503 (Mr
Fedorovtsev).
12. On 30 October 2017, WADA’s Intelligence & Investigation Department (“WADA I&I”) obtained the Laboratory Information Management System (“LIMS”) data of the Moscow Laboratory from a whistleblower (“2015 LIMS Copy”).
13. In January 2019, WADA I&I was given access to the Moscow Laboratory and secured additional data, including a copy of the LIMS data (“2019 LIMS Copy”) as well as the underlying analytical documents of the analyses reported in the LIMS.
14. Upon receipt of information and documents from WADA, WR carried out a review relating to the Athletes’ samples identified above. WR was satisfied that the Athletes had committed ADRVs.
documents of the analyses reported in the LIMS.
14. Upon receipt of information and documents from WADA, WR carried out a review relating to the Athletes’ samples identified above. WR was satisfied that the Athletes had committed ADRVs.
15. On 13 April 2021, WR notified the Athletes that ADRVs were being asserted against them under Article 2.2 of the 2009 ADR (the “Notifications”). A provisional suspension was imposed upon the Athletes with immediate effect pursuant to the 2009 ADR and the 2021 edition of the FISA AntiDoping Bye-Laws (the “WR ADR”).
16. On 27 April 2021, the Athletes submitted responses to the Notification s, disputing the assertions made against them. Mr Ryabtsev, Mr Kleshnev, and Mr Fedorovtsev also requested provisional hearings to challenge the provisional suspensions as per Article 7.4.3 of the WR ADR.
17. On 31 May 2021, WR informed the Athletes that it was WR’s opinion that there were no grounds to lift the provisional suspension s imposed. WR invited the Athletes to confirm by 21 June 2021 whether they agreed to an expedited final hearing on the merits of the cases before the Anti-Doping Division of the Court of Arbitration for Sport (the “ADD”) instead of provisional hearings.
18. On 21 June 2021, Messrs Ryabtsev, Kleshnev, and Fedorovtsev maintained their requests for provisional hearings. Mr Mikhaylevskiy submitted that his case should be adjudicated in the normal procedure as provided for in Article 8 of the WR ADR.
19. On 5 July 2021, WR informed the Athletes that the matters pertaining to the provisional suspensions imposed on Messrs Ryabtsev, Kleshnev, and Fedorovtsev would be submitted for adjudication to the ADD for provisional hearings.
20. On 3 August 2021, Mr Ryabtsev informed WR that he intended to participate in national
imposed on Messrs Ryabtsev, Kleshnev, and Fedorovtsev would be submitted for adjudication to the ADD for provisional hearings.
20. On 3 August 2021, Mr Ryabtsev informed WR that he intended to participate in national competitions that were scheduled to commence on 13 August 2021. He submitted that the denial of a provisional hearing constituted “ irreparable harm which justifies the immediate lifting of the Provisional
Suspension”.CAS Anti-Doping Division Chambre Anti-dopage du TAS 2021/ADD/29 World Rowing v. Vladislav Ryabtsev, 2021/ADD/36 World Rowing v. Denis Kleshnev, 2021/ADD/39 World Rowing v. Vyacheslav Mikhaylevskiy, 2021/ADD/40 World Rowing v. Sergej Fedorovtsev - Page 4
613 50 00 Fax: +41 (21) 613 50 01 procedures@tas-cas.org
21. On 4 August 2021, WR informed Mr Ryabtsev that it had taken notice of his intent to participate in an upcoming event and stated that it would refer the matter to the ADD by the end of 6 August
2021.
22. On 1 September 2021, Mr Fedorovtsev sent WR a letter requesting the immediate lifting of his provisional suspension.
23. On 6 September 2021, WR lifted Mr Fedorovtsev’s provisional suspension with immediate effect, basing its decision essentially on Mr Fedorovtsev having already served a period of ineligibility of four years.
III. PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE COURT OF ARBITRATION FOR SPORT
A. Related prior proceedings
24. On 5 August 2021, WR filed with the ADD an application in accordance with Article 7.4.3 of the WR ADR. The application contained requests to maintain the provisional suspensions imposed on
Mr Ryabtsev and Mr Kleshnev.
A. Related prior proceedings
24. On 5 August 2021, WR filed with the ADD an application in accordance with Article 7.4.3 of the WR ADR. The application contained requests to maintain the provisional suspensions imposed on
Mr Ryabtsev and Mr Kleshnev.
25. On 6 August 2021, Mr Ryabtsev filed an application for provisional measures with the ADD.
26. On 13 August 2021, the President of the ADD dismissed Mr Ryabtsev’s application.
27. On 30 September 2021, the ADD issued two Orders on Lifting of Provisional Suspension and upheld WR’s requests to maintain the provisional suspensions imposed on 13 April 2021 against Mr
Ryabtsev and Mr Kleshnev.
B. Proceedings under Article 8 of the WR ADR and Article A13 of the ADD Rules
28. On 10 November 2021, WR filed with the ADD four separate Requests for Disciplinary Proceedings in relation to the Athletes (the “Requests for Disciplinary Proceedings”) in accordance with Article 8 of the WR ADR and Article A13 of the 2021 edition of the Arbitration Rules of the CAS AntiDoping Division (“ADD Rules”). The Requests for Disciplinary Proceedings contained a request to consolidate the proceedings of the four Athletes.
29. On 15 November 2021, the ADD informed WADA of the Requests for Disciplinary Proceedings and of its right under Article A14 of the ADD Rules and Article R41.3 of the Code of Sports-related Arbitration (the “Code”) to participate as a party in the present arbitration.
30. On the same day, the ADD invited the Athletes to file with the ADD answers to the Requests for Disciplinary Proceedings (the “Answer”). The ADD also invited the Athletes to inform the ADD whether they agree to consolidate the proceedings.
31. On 19 November 2021, the Athletes requested an extension of their deadline to file their Answers until 24 March 2022.
Disciplinary Proceedings (the “Answer”). The ADD also invited the Athletes to inform the ADD whether they agree to consolidate the proceedings.
31. On 19 November 2021, the Athletes requested an extension of their deadline to file their Answers until 24 March 2022.
32. On 22 November 2021, WADA informed the ADD that it does not intend to participate in the arbitrations concerning Mr Ryabtsev and Mr Kleshnev.
33. On 23 November 2021, the Athletes filed their replies to WR’s request to consolidate the proceedings of the four Athletes, objecting to the consolidation. The Athletes stated that they would, however, agree to file a joint Answer and to have a joint hearing on the issues that are common for all the Athletes, provided that they are allowed to file separate submission s addressing factual andCAS Anti-Doping Division
Chambre Anti-dopage du TAS 2021/ADD/29 World Rowing v. Vladislav Ryabtsev, 2021/ADD/36 World Rowing v. Denis Kleshnev, 2021/ADD/39 World Rowing v. Vyacheslav Mikhaylevskiy, 2021/ADD/40 World Rowing v. Sergej Fedorovtsev - Page 5
613 50 00 Fax: +41 (21) 613 50 01 procedures@tas-cas.org legal arguments specific to each of them and have them heard separately, should the defence of their cases so require.
34. On 24 November 2021, WR informed the ADD that it maintains its request for consolidation and leaves the decision on consolidation to the discretion of the President of the ADD.
35. On 25 November 2021, WADA informed the ADD that it does not intend to participate in the arbitrations concerning Mr Mikhaylevskiy and Mr Fedorovtsev.
36. On 1 December 2021, the ADD informed the Parties that the Athletes’ request for an extension to
arbitrations concerning Mr Mikhaylevskiy and Mr Fedorovtsev.
36. On 1 December 2021, the ADD informed the Parties that the Athletes’ request for an extension to file their Answers is granted and the deadline is extended until 24 March 2022. In addition, the ADD informed that WR’s request for consolidation is denied and the four matters will be adjudicated separately. However, the President of the ADD allowed the filing of a joint Answer as well as the holding of a joint hearing and joint correspondence. Finally, the ADD invited the Parties to liaise with each other with the aim of reaching an agreement on the appointment of the sole arbitrator in the matters.
37. On 22 December 2021, WR informed the ADD that the Parties were unable to reach an agreement as to the appointment of the sole arbitrator.
38. On 18 February 2022, the ADD informed the Parties that Mr Manninen had been appointed by the President of the ADD as the Sole Arbitrator in accordance with Articles A16 and A17 of the ADD
Rules.
39. On 25 February 2022, the Athletes challenged the appointment of Mr Manninen pursuant to Article A10 of the ADD Rules.
40. On 24 March 2022, the Athletes filed their joint Answer to the Requests for Disciplinary Proceedings
(the “Joint Answer”), containing a request to lift the provisional suspensions imposed on Messrs Ryabtsev, Kleshnev, and Mikhaylevskiy and a request for production of documents (“Request for Document Production”).
41. On 6 March 2024, the ADD provided the Parties with the Decision rendered by the Challenge Commission of the International Council of Arbitration for Sport . The Challenge Commission dismissed the petition for challenge to the appointment of Mr Manninen.
42. On 11 March 2024, the ADD invited WR to comment on the Athletes’ Request for Document Production dated 24 March 2022. Concurrently, the ADD invited WR to file a preliminary opinion on the Athletes’ request to be granted a second round of written submissions.
42. On 11 March 2024, the ADD invited WR to comment on the Athletes’ Request for Document Production dated 24 March 2022. Concurrently, the ADD invited WR to file a preliminary opinion on the Athletes’ request to be granted a second round of written submissions.
43. On 18 April 2024, WR requested to be given the opportunity to file additional submissions as per Article 19.2 of the ADD Rules. Regarding the Request for Document Production, WR clarified that none of the documents sought by the Athletes were in the “possession, custody, or control” of WR at the time the disclosure request was made. WR consulted WADA as a gesture of good faith and submitted WADA’s responses to each of the 15 document production requests made by the Athletes.
Furthermore, WR requested the opportunity to submit into the case file the entirety of WADA’s response and submitted part of the requested documents.
44. On 26 April 2024, the ADD informed the Parties that their request to file further written submissions was granted. The ADD also invited the Athletes to confirm whether their Request for Document Production had been satisfied and, if not, to identify which documents are missing and reasons why such documents should be produced by WR. Finally, the ADD confirmed that WADA’s statement described by WR in its letter of 18 April 2024 was admitted to the case file.CAS Anti-Doping Division
Chambre Anti-dopage du TAS 2021/ADD/29 World Rowing v. Vladislav Ryabtsev, 2021/ADD/36 World Rowing v. Denis Kleshnev, 2021/ADD/39 World Rowing v. Vyacheslav Mikhaylevskiy, 2021/ADD/40 World Rowing v. Sergej Fedorovtsev - Page 6
613 50 00 Fax: +41 (21) 613 50 01 procedures@tas-cas.org
45. On 30 April 2024, WR submitted WADA’s statement dated 17 April 2024.
613 50 00 Fax: +41 (21) 613 50 01 procedures@tas-cas.org
45. On 30 April 2024, WR submitted WADA’s statement dated 17 April 2024.
46. On 17 May 2024, the Athletes submitted that, in their view, the document production was not complete. The Athletes specifically identified attachments ARW -1 to ARW-13 to the “Chain of Custody Statement” by Mr Walker dated 5 March 2021 and Annexures A, C, F, G, and H to the “Final report to the CRC regarding the Moscow Data” dated 20 November 2019 (“CRC Report”) as not having been produced. The Athletes also submitted a Redfern Schedule including all 15 requests, an explanation of their relevance, WR’s responses to each request, and the Athletes’ observations.
47. On 4 June 2024, the ADD informed the Parties of the Sole Arbitrator’s decision regarding the Athletes’ Request for Document Production. In his decision, the Sole Arbitrator dismissed requests 1, 2, 3, 4, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, and 15 based on the requested documents not being in the possession or under the control of WR. The Sole Arbitrator further noted that requests 5, 6, and 14 had been satisfied or that there were no pending requests. Regarding request 13, the Sole Arbitrator stated that it was pending and needed further clarification. The Sole Arbitrator invited WR to respond to the specified document production request.
48. On 21 June 2024, WR submitted attachments ARW-1 to ARW-13 to the “Chain of Custody Statement” by Mr Walker dated 5 March 2021 and Annexures A, C, F, G, and H to the CRC Report.
49. On 27 June 2024, the ADD noted that the document “WADA New Data Report (PFS 19.0431)” is
by Mr Walker dated 5 March 2021 and Annexures A, C, F, G, and H to the CRC Report.
49. On 27 June 2024, the ADD noted that the document “WADA New Data Report (PFS 19.0431)” is missing and invited WR to produce. In addition, the ADD invited WR to file its Reply to the
Athletes’ Answer.
50. On 15 July 2024, the Athletes submitted a Second Request for Document Production (“Second Request for Document Production”). The Athletes requested WR to produce “[a]ll documents received by and sent by WADA and W orld Rowing in connection to the WADA/RUSADA post February 2021 investigation (including the re-analysis of the Athletes’ Samples: (…)), carried out at the request of WADA, notably following Mr Younger’s letter to RUSADA dated 2 February 2021”.
51. On the same day, the ADD invited WR to comment on the Athletes’ Second Request for Document
Production.
52. On 25 July 2024, the ADD noted that no communication was received from WR within the time limit granted.
53. On 30 July 2024, the ADD informed the Parties that the Sole Arbitrator had granted the Athletes’ Second Request for Document Production to the extent the requested documents were in WR’s possession or under its control.
54. On 26 August 2024, WR submitted a document titled “WADA New Data Report (PFS 19.0431) ”.
With respect to the Athletes’ Second Request for Document Production, WR submitted that WADA did not have any documents to provide in response to the Athletes’ request. WR also referred to the Addendum Joint Statement of Mr Walker and Dr Broséus of WADA dated 17 April 2024, where they submitted that “the samples associated with the Athletes in respect of this [sic] cases have been discarded and therefore cannot be found and anlyzed. Additionally, the associated chain of custody documents has [sic] not been
they submitted that “the samples associated with the Athletes in respect of this [sic] cases have been discarded and therefore cannot be found and anlyzed. Additionally, the associated chain of custody documents has [sic] not been found. As detailed in the Joint Statement, such records have been removed from the Moscow Laboratory by the Investigative Committee and are inaccessible to WADA.”
55. On 28 August 2024, and further to granted extensions of time, WR filed its Reply to the Athletes’
Joint Answer.
56. On 27 November 2024, and further to granted extensions of time the Athletes filed their joint
Rejoinder.CAS Anti-Doping Division Chambre Anti-dopage du TAS 2021/ADD/29 World Rowing v. Vladislav Ryabtsev, 2021/ADD/36 World Rowing v. Denis Kleshnev, 2021/ADD/39 World Rowing v. Vyacheslav Mikhaylevskiy, 2021/ADD/40 World Rowing v. Sergej Fedorovtsev - Page 7
613 50 00 Fax: +41 (21) 613 50 01 procedures@tas-cas.org
57. On 28 November 2024, the ADD invited the Parties to state whether they consider a hearing necessary in the procedure.
58. On 11 December 2024, the Athletes submitted that they consider a hearing necessary and requested that it be held. On the same day, WR submitted that the final decision could be issued solely on the basis of the Parties’ written submissions.
59. On 16 December 2024, the ADD informed the Parties that the Sole Arbitrator had decided to hold a hearing in the matters.
60. On 20 March 2025, the ADD called the Parties and their witnesses to appear at a hearing to be held by videoconference on 7 April 2025. The ADD reminded the Parties of their responsibility for the availability of the witnesses and experts to be heard at the hearing. The Parties were also requested to provide the names of all persons attending the hearing.
by videoconference on 7 April 2025. The ADD reminded the Parties of their responsibility for the availability of the witnesses and experts to be heard at the hearing. The Parties were also requested to provide the names of all persons attending the hearing.
61. On 26 March 2025, the Athletes submitted their list of participants to the hearing.
62. On 27 March 2025, WR submitted its list of participants to the hearing.
63. On 28 March 2025, the Athletes submitted the following additions to their list of participants to the hearing, to only participate during the examination of WR’s experts (Professors Souvignet and
Casey): Mr Bev Clues and Ms Lisa Barnes.
64. On the same day, WR submitted that the Athletes’ announcement of the participation of additional experts was done belatedly and without specifying their role or area of expertise. WR reserved the right to call additional experts, depending on the clarifications to be provided by the Athletes.
65. On the same day, the ADD invited the Athletes to explain the reasons for the attendance of Mr Clues and Ms Barnes during the examination of WR’s experts and the capacity in which they would appear at the hearing.
66. On 31 March 2025, the Athletes clarified that Mr Clues and Ms Barnes were retained as additional counsel by the Athletes because of their expertise in technical issues (computer forensics).
67. On 1 April 2025, the ADD provided to the Parties the Order of Procedure, inviting the Parties to sign and return it. In addition, the ADD stated that Mr Clues and Ms Barnes were allowed to attend the hearing during the examination of the experts called by WR as they were acting as counsel for the Athletes and not as experts.
68. On 2 April 2025, ITA submitted the Order of Procedure signed on behalf of WR.
69. On 3 April 2025, the Athletes submitted the Order of Procedure signed on behalf of the Athletes.
70. On 7 April 2025, a video hearing was held. The Sole Arbitrator was assisted by Mr Fabien Cagneux,
69. On 3 April 2025, the Athletes submitted the Order of Procedure signed on behalf of the Athletes.
70. On 7 April 2025, a video hearing was held. The Sole Arbitrator was assisted by Mr Fabien Cagneux, Managing Counsel of the ADD, and joined by the following:
For WR:
- Ms Ayesha Talpade, Senior Legal Counsel, the ITA
- Mr Anton Sotir, Senior Legal Counsel, the ITA
- Professor Eoghan Casey, Expert WitnessCAS Anti-Doping Division
Chambre Anti-dopage du TAS 2021/ADD/29 World Rowing v. Vladislav Ryabtsev, 2021/ADD/36 World Rowing v. Denis Kleshnev, 2021/ADD/39 World Rowing v. Vyacheslav Mikhaylevskiy, 2021/ADD/40 World Rowing v. Sergej Fedorovtsev - Page 8
613 50 00 Fax: +41 (21) 613 50 01 procedures@tas-cas.org
- Professor Thomas Souvignet, Expert Witness
- Professor Christiane Ayotte, Expert Witness
For the Athletes:
- Mr Andrea Pinna, Counsel
- Ms Olga Cucu, Counsel
- Mr Bev Clues, Counsel
- Ms Lisa Barnes, Counsel - Athletes (partly)
- Professor Pascal Kintz, Expert Witness
71. During the hearing, the Athletes submitted that the expert reports by Mr Sheldon, Mr Walker , and Dr Broséus shall be deemed inadmissible considering that WR did not call said experts to appear at the hearing for the Athletes’ cross-examination. WR objected to the Athletes’ position essentially on the ground that the Athletes never indicated any wish to cross -examine them. According to Article 19.3 of the ADD Rules, referred to in the Order of Procedure,“[t]he parties may call only such witnesses and experts as they have identified in their written submissions. Each party is responsible for the availability (…) of
the ground that the Athletes never indicated any wish to cross -examine them. According to Article 19.3 of the ADD Rules, referred to in the Order of Procedure,“[t]he parties may call only such witnesses and experts as they have identified in their written submissions. Each party is responsible for the availability (…) of the witnesses and experts it has called.” The Sole Arbitrator found that this provision does not clearly obligate a party to call an expert to appear at a hearing for cross -examination unless there is an indication by the counterparty that it wants to use its right to cross -examine the expert. A different interpretation would not be aligned with the arbitration practice and would likely lead to increased inefficiency. Therefore, the Sole Arbitrator f ound that WR had a justified understanding that there is no need to call Mr Sheldon, Mr Walker , and Dr Broséus to the hearing. On these grounds, the Sole Arbitrator found the expert reports admissible but ordered that another hearing day be arranged for the Athletes to have an opportunity to cross-examine said experts, thus safeguarding the Athletes’ right to plead their respective cases.
72. During the hearing, the lifting of the provisional suspensions was also discussed. Messrs Ryabtsev, Kleshnev, and Mikhaylevskiy reiterated their request for the lifting of their provisional suspensions as from 13 April 2025 at the latest. They submitted that even if WR’s requests for the ineligibility periods to be imposed would be granted in full, the provisional suspensions could not last beyond 12 April 2025. WR left the issue to the Sole Arbitrator’s consideration.
73. Finally, WR stated that it prefers one joint Award over separate Awards for all four Athletes. T he Athletes noted that, as most issues are common for all the Athletes , only one award is required insofar as separate reasonings and reliefs are included for each Athlete.
74. After the discussions, opening statements by the Parties, and examination of four expert witnesses,
Athletes noted that, as most issues are common for all the Athletes , only one award is required insofar as separate reasonings and reliefs are included for each Athlete.
74. After the discussions, opening statements by the Parties, and examination of four expert witnesses, the hearing was suspended to be reconvened at a later date suitable for the Sole Arbitrator, the ADD, the Parties, and the remaining experts to be examined.
75. On 14 April 2025, the ADD rendered a Partial Award on the lifting of provisional suspension s imposed on Messrs Ryabtsev, Kleshnev, and Mikhaylevskiy . The Sole Arbitrator granted the Athletes’ request and lifted the provisional suspensions imposed on the three Athletes on 13 April 2021 with immediate effect.CAS Anti-Doping Division
Chambre Anti-dopage du TAS 2021/ADD/29 World Rowing v. Vladislav Ryabtsev, 2021/ADD/36 World Row
Estás viendo una vista previa
Lee el documento completo con Ariel
Este es un fragmento de uno de los más de 1.2 millones de documentos de la biblioteca de Ariel. Crea tu cuenta para leerlo completo, descargarlo y consultarlo con Ariel, que siempre te lleva a la fuente exacta: Ariel NO alucina.