TSDJ CLO SC - 760013103009201800099-01 (2398)-(03-11-2021)

REPÚBLICA DE COLOMBIA

DEPARTAMENTO DEL VALLE DEL CAUCA

RAMA JUDICIAL DEL PODER PÚBLICO

TRIBUNAL SUPERIOR DEL DISTRITO JUDICIAL DE CALI

SALA DE DECISIÓN CIVIL

ACTA DE DISCUSION No. 020-2021

Santiago de Cali, tres (3) de noviembre dos mil veintiuno (2021)

En la ciudad de Santiago de Cali, el día tres (3) de noviembre de los dos mil veintiuno (2021), el Magistrado Dr. César Evaristo León Vergara manifestó su conformidad con el proyecto de sentencia en el cual funge como ponente el Magistrado Dr. Jorge Jaramillo Villarreal en el siguiente proceso:

RADICACIÓN: Rad. No. 76-001-31-03-009-2018-00099-01 (2398)

PROCESO: Verbal Declarativo

DEMANDANTE: Fundación Santa Fe de Bogotá

DEMANDADA: Coomeva E.P.S.

OBSERVACIONES

A través de medios electrónicos el proyecto fue enviado al magistrado integrante de la Sala de Decisión quien luego de estudiar el asunto, por la misma vía de comunicación manifestó estar de acuerdo.

Los Magistrados,

JORGE JARAMILLO VILLARREAL

CÉSAR EVARISTO LEÓN VERGARA ANA LUZ ESOBAR LOZANO

En Licencia DECLARATIVO Rad. No. 76-001-31-03-009-2018-00099-01 (2398)República de Colombia

Rama Judicial del Poder Público

TRIBUNAL SUPERIOR DEL DISTRITO JUDICIAL DE CALI

En Licencia DECLARATIVO Rad. No. 76-001-31-03-009-2018-00099-01 (2398)República de Colombia

Rama Judicial del Poder Público

TRIBUNAL SUPERIOR DEL DISTRITO JUDICIAL DE CALI

SALA DE DECISIÓN CIVIL

DECLARATIVO Rad. No. 76-001-31-03-009-2018-00099-01 (2398)

MAGISTRADO PONENTE: JORGE JARAMILLO VILLARREAL

ESTA SENTENCIA FUE APROBADA SEGÚN ACTA DE DISCUSIÓN No. -

020-2021 DE LA FECHA.

Santiago de Cali, tres (3) de noviembre de dos mil veintiuno (2021)

Se decide la apelación presentada por la entidad demanda da contra la sentencia proferida por el Juzgado Noveno Civil del Circuito de Cali, dentro del proceso verbal declarativo propuesto por la Fundación Santa Fe de Bogotá en contra de Coomeva E.P.S. , en la que se accedieron a las pretensiones de manera parcial.

1.- ANTECEDENTES

La demanda y contestación admiten el siguiente resumen:

1.1.- Como hechos se relata que COOMEVA E.P.S., con el fin de cumplir las obligaciones impuestas por la ley 100 de 1993, suscribió con la FUNDACION SANTA FE DE BOGOTA, los siguientes convenios en los que se acordaron los términos en que se prestaría la atención en salud de la población perteneciente al régimen contributivo en cuanto a servicios médicos, tarifas y periodos contratados:

a) Convenio de Términos de referencia de fecha 1 de enero de

población perteneciente al régimen contributivo en cuanto a servicios médicos, tarifas y periodos contratados:

a) Convenio de Términos de referencia de fecha 1 de enero de 2013 cuyo objeto consistió en la prestación de servicios de salud para losAPELACIÓN DE SENTENCIA 009-2018-00099-01 (2398)

FUNDACION SANTA FE DE BOGOTA VS COOMEVA EPS

2

afiliados cotizantes y beneficiarios de Coomeva E.P.S. en la modalidad por evento y paquete , servicios contratados P.O.S. y no P.O.S. descritos en el numeral IV, duración del contrato: “once” (sic) meses contados desde el 1 de enero de 2013 al 31 de diciembre de 2013, prorrogable automáticamente si ninguna de las partes manifestaba la intención de no continuar , como valor del contrato se fijó la suma de $9.587.610.000 , el plazo para el pago se estableció el término de 90 días para las facturas radicadas hasta el 31 de marzo de 2013 y para las posteriores se convino un término de 60 días.

b) Carta de acuerdo COOMEVA E.P.S. – FUNDACION SANTA FE DE BOGOTA de fecha 1 de enero de 2014 , cuyo objeto consistió en la prestación de servicios de salud para los afiliados cotizantes y beneficiarios de Coomeva E.P.S. en la modalidad de paquete , servicios que incluyen : Trasplante Hepático, Epilepsia, Aislamiento Venas Pulmonares, Duplex Scan de Vasos de Pene a color e Interrupción voluntaria del Embarazo , como duración del contrato se estableció el término de doce meses contados desde

Trasplante Hepático, Epilepsia, Aislamiento Venas Pulmonares, Duplex Scan de Vasos de Pene a color e Interrupción voluntaria del Embarazo , como duración del contrato se estableció el término de doce meses contados desde el 1 de enero de 2014 al 31 de diciembre de 2014, no se fijó valor del contrato, no obstante, este será el resultado de multiplicar el número de procedimientos practicados por el valor pactado para cada uno de ellos.

Expresa que las relaciones surgidas entre la I.P.S. y la EPS COOMEVA, se encuentran reglamentadas por la ley 100 de 1993, Decreto 046 de 2000, la Ley 715 de 2001, la Ley 1122 de 2007 y la Ley 1438 de 2011, Art.8 del Decreto 046 de 2000 y Art.617 del Estatuto Tributario , normas que han definido los requisitos que deben reunir las facturas de ventas de servicios de salud.

Que la Fundación, en cumplimiento de la obligación legal y de los términos de referencia pactados entre las partes, brindó atención médica a los afiliados (cotizantes y beneficiarios) de COOMEVA y por tales conceptos presentó las facturas que a continuación se relacionan:

FACTURA FECHA DE

RADICACION VALOR INICIAL PAGOS

APLICADOS

NOTAS CREDITO SALDO POR PAGAR FSFB02216869 10/01/2012 633.622 567.357 12.665 53.600

FSFB02253901 10/04/2012 107.656.647 102.011.961 5.520.702 123.984

FSFB02216869 10/01/2012 633.622 567.357 12.665 53.600

FSFB02253901 10/04/2012 107.656.647 102.011.961 5.520.702 123.984

FSFB02233232 10/04/2012 55.954.695 53.326.211 2.045.153 583.331APELACIÓN DE SENTENCIA

009-2018-00099-01 (2398)

FUNDACION SANTA FE DE BOGOTA VS COOMEVA EPS

3

FSFB02280119 30/04/2012 8.117.327 7.475.261 143.448 498.618

FSFB02299245 02/05/2012 15.838.128 6.913.023 - 8.925.105

FSFB02380764 03/07/2012 339.917 - - 339.917

FSFB02376145 06/07/2012 101.136 58.685 34.160 8.291

FSFB02383752 06/07/2012 652.408 571.640 - 80.768

FSFB02384375 06/07/2012 567.006 496.810 - 70.196

FSFB02384883 06/07/2012 104.338 91.421 - 12.917

FSFB02385664 06/07/2012 6.807.422 5.964.664 - 842.758

FSFB02346690 11/07/2012 2.472.908 1.469.317 795.990 207.601

FSFB02385664 06/07/2012 6.807.422 5.964.664 - 842.758

FSFB02346690 11/07/2012 2.472.908 1.469.317 795.990 207.601

FSFB02360590 11/07/2012 1.327.873 1.148.392 17.222 162.259

FSFB02357495 11/07/2012 461.106 348.518 63.345 49.243

FSFB02360711 11/07/2012 490.127 424.533 5.611 59.983

FSFB02362987 11/07/2012 492.341 431.389 - 60.952

FSFB02366164 11/07/2012 66.163 52.640 6.085 7.438

FSFB02368295 11/07/2012 115.282 49.390 58.914 6.978

FSFB02378403 11/07/2012 207.134 181.491 - 25.643

FSFB02379479 11/07/2012 131.943 93.455 25.284 13.204

FSFB02327693 12/07/2012 869.495 662.960 112.865 93.670

FSFB02345229 12/07/2012 16.367.124 12.929.739 1.610.517 1.826.868

FSFB02365668 12/07/2012 325.537 284.739 566 40.232

FSFB02375770 12/07/2012 1.545.140 1.331.698 25.284 188.158

FSFB02365668 12/07/2012 325.537 284.739 566 40.232

FSFB02375770 12/07/2012 1.545.140 1.331.698 25.284 188.158

FSFB02366160 19/07/2012 1.210.928 1.047.268 15.690 147.970

FSFB02385652 19/07/2012 4.816.000 4.219.779 - 596.221

FSFB02392688 19/07/2012 160.024 140.213 - 19.811

FSFB02395816 19/07/2012 46.134 40.422 - 5.712

FSFB02320714 19/07/2012 72.120 63.192 - 8.928

FSFB02338320 19/07/2012 133.065 116.592 - 16.473

FSFB02387034 19/07/2012 74.852 65.585 - 9.267

FSFB02387443 19/07/2012 1.157.200 1.013.939 - 143.261

FSFB02391439 19/07/2012 215.064 188.439 - 26.625

FSFB02391662 19/07/2012 186.408 163.331 - 23.077

FSFB02381920 19/07/2012 42.436 37.182 - 5.254

FSFB02382474 19/07/2012 94.690 82.967 - 11.723

FSFB02387153 19/07/2012 42.760 37.466 - 5.294

FSFB02382474 19/07/2012 94.690 82.967 - 11.723

FSFB02387153 19/07/2012 42.760 37.466 - 5.294

FSFB02382532 19/07/2012 42.160 36.940 - 5.220

FSFB02382777 19/07/2012 128.906 112.947 - 15.959

FSFB02382961 19/07/2012 48.178 42.213 - 5.965

FSFB02383088 19/07/2012 348.665 305.500 - 43.165

FSFB02380724 19/07/2012 611.077 535.426 - 75.651

FSFB02381354 19/07/2012 134.319 117.690 - 16.629

FSFB02381527 19/07/2012 98.561 86.359 - 12.202

FSFB02381860 19/07/2012 129.878 113.799 - 16.079

FSFB02381882 19/07/2012 327.765 287.188 - 40.577

FSFB02382382 19/07/2012 185.160 162.237 - 22.923

FSFB02383182 19/07/2012 136.910 119.961 - 16.949

FSFB02383570 19/07/2012 139.433 122.171 - 17.262

FSFB02384487 19/07/2012 228.086 199.849 - 28.237

FSFB02383570 19/07/2012 139.433 122.171 - 17.262

FSFB02384487 19/07/2012 228.086 199.849 - 28.237

FSFB02387217 19/07/2012 1.778.024 1.557.904 - 220.120

FSFB02387591 19/07/2012 132.747 116.313 - 16.434

FSFB02387658 19/07/2012 168.736 147.846 - 20.890APELACIÓN DE SENTENCIA

009-2018-00099-01 (2398)

FUNDACION SANTA FE DE BOGOTA VS COOMEVA EPS

4

FSFB02387672 19/07/2012 178.826 156.687 - 22.139

FSFB02388815 19/07/2012 157.894 138.347 - 19.547

FSFB02382950 19/07/2012 319.494 279.941 - 39.553

FSFB02392465 19/07/2012 99.736 87.389 - 12.347

FSFB02394818 19/07/2012 128.224 112.350 - 15.874

FSFB02399700 19/07/2012 54.058 47.366 - 6.692

FSFB02315673 19/07/2012 560.832 491.401 - 69.431

FSFB02363568 19/07/2012 5.910.434 4.346.164 950.192 614.078

FSFB02315673 19/07/2012 560.832 491.401 - 69.431

FSFB02363568 19/07/2012 5.910.434 4.346.164 950.192 614.078

FSFB02369641 19/07/2012 969.927 574.324 314.455 81.148

FSFB02373962 19/07/2012 158.124 138.548 - 19.576

FSFB02417637 15/08/2012 4.863.700 - 155.638 4.708.062

FSFB02418407 10/10/2012 18.286.402 18.069.763 16.920 199.719

FSFB02483402 22/10/2012 47.210.018 39.221.148 2.561.314 5.427.556

FSFB02486564 03/12/2012 1.938.220 1.871.462 5.904 60.854

FSFB02497836 03/12/2012 10.429.776 9.934.207 262.495 233.074

FSFB02505145 03/12/2012 1.897.321 1.722.815 86.517 87.989

FSFB02507742 03/12/2012 2.157.399 2.114.251 - 43.148

FSFB02508043 03/12/2012 2.392.738 2.344.883 - 47.855

FSFB02511874 03/12/2012 11.571.200 11.339.776 - 231.424

FSFB02508043 03/12/2012 2.392.738 2.344.883 - 47.855

FSFB02511874 03/12/2012 11.571.200 11.339.776 - 231.424

FSFB02279914 10/12/2012 16.403.732 13.943.079 2.176.100 284.553

FSFB02492542 10/12/2012 1.114.765 1.084.913 2.952 26.900

FSFB02512263 10/12/2012 3.663.270 3.446.170 146.770 70.330

FSFB02516277 10/12/2012 3.981.857 3.720.856 184.596 76.405

FSFB02516286 10/12/2012 1.084.190 977.760 86.476 19.954

FSFB02520019 10/12/2012 698.475 682.690 - 15.785

FSFB02528930 10/12/2012 3.770.213 3.691.557 - 78.656

FSFB02529701 10/12/2012 1.013.790 993.470 - 20.320

FSFB02536561 10/12/2012 10.491.014 10.281.194 - 209.820

FSFB02536583 10/12/2012 5.541.509 5.430.679 - 110.830

FSFB02538065 10/12/2012 888.259 870.450 - 17.809

FSFB02538547 10/12/2012 10.484.490 10.274.800 - 209.690

FSFB02538065 10/12/2012 888.259 870.450 - 17.809

FSFB02538547 10/12/2012 10.484.490 10.274.800 - 209.690

FSFB02538794 10/12/2012 4.457.544 4.368.393 - 89.151

FSFB02494312 10/12/2012 1.388.514 1.360.700 - 27.814

FSFB02508727 10/12/2012 5.783.282 5.118.226 562.802 102.254

FSFB02540508 10/12/2012 6.852.300 6.715.254 - 137.046

FSFB02504227 10/12/2012 6.093.917 5.881.240 92.652 120.025

FSFB02512371 10/12/2012 1.765.915 1.223.133 509.994 32.788

FSFB02521077 10/12/2012 779.004 699.811 64.911 14.282

FSFB02536172 10/12/2012 4.970.447 4.689.730 101.940 178.777

FSFB02536795 10/12/2012 9.047.312 8.749.360 42.722 255.230

FSFB02542563 02/01/2013 434.352 394.486 - 39.866

FSFB02545790 02/01/2013 530.810 520.194 - 10.616

FSFB02545968 02/01/2013 1.157.200 1.148.101 - 9.099

FSFB02545790 02/01/2013 530.810 520.194 - 10.616

FSFB02545968 02/01/2013 1.157.200 1.148.101 - 9.099

FSFB02547366 02/01/2013 555.708 542.468 - 13.240

FSFB02498035 02/01/2013 5.787.680 5.579.564 - 208.116

FSFB02532970 02/01/2013 1.024.122 1.000.978 - 23.144

FSFB02533287 02/01/2013 55.141 49.075 - 6.066

FSFB02533303 02/01/2013 42.641 36.575 - 6.066

FSFB02533340 02/01/2013 45.741 39.675 - 6.066

FSFB02534364 02/01/2013 322.596 287.110 - 35.486APELACIÓN DE SENTENCIA

009-2018-00099-01 (2398)

FUNDACION SANTA FE DE BOGOTA VS COOMEVA EPS

5

FSFB02534492 02/01/2013 322.596 287.110 - 35.486

FSFB02534750 02/01/2013 215.064 191.407 - 23.657

FSFB02537784 02/01/2013 623.960 602.121 - 21.839

FSFB02538662 02/01/2013 55.141 49.075 - 6.066

FSFB02538664 02/01/2013 55.141 49.075 - 6.066

FSFB02538662 02/01/2013 55.141 49.075 - 6.066

FSFB02538664 02/01/2013 55.141 49.075 - 6.066

FSFB02538669 02/01/2013 55.141 49.075 - 6.066

FSFB02539386 02/01/2013 55.141 49.075 - 6.066

FSFB02459592 02/01/2013 630.037 615.799 - 14.238

FSFB02505314 02/01/2013 798.451 784.282 - 14.169

FSFB02534305 02/01/2013 215.064 191.407 - 23.657

FSFB02538652 02/01/2013 63.600 49.075 8.459 6.066

FSFB02540919 02/01/2013 66.344 57.319 - 9.025

FSFB02541131 02/01/2013 88.355 49.075 33.214 6.066

FSFB02541581 02/01/2013 1.122.400 1.099.952 - 22.448

FSFB02541677 02/01/2013 8.387.592 8.094.026 - 293.566

FSFB02516299 02/01/2013 4.845.120 4.675.541 - 169.579

FSFB02545354 02/01/2013 322.596 287.110 - 35.486

FSFB02545414 02/01/2013 215.064 191.407 - 23.657

FSFB02545354 02/01/2013 322.596 287.110 - 35.486

FSFB02545414 02/01/2013 215.064 191.407 - 23.657

FSFB02548948 02/01/2013 6.206.486 5.989.259 - 217.227

FSFB02550410 02/01/2013 273.480 243.397 - 30.083

FSFB02550412 02/01/2013 136.740 121.699 - 15.041

FSFB02550414 02/01/2013 54.696 48.679 - 6.017

FSFB02554403 02/01/2013 191.436 170.378 - 21.058

FSFB02554506 02/01/2013 258.800 252.952 - 5.848

FSFB02554542 02/01/2013 45.741 39.675 - 6.066

FSFB02554568 02/01/2013 55.141 49.075 - 6.066

FSFB02554707 02/01/2013 55.141 49.075 - 6.066

FSFB02554722 02/01/2013 48.841 42.775 - 6.066

FSFB02554854 02/01/2013 48.841 42.775 - 6.066

FSFB02554947 02/01/2013 2.451.446 2.365.645 - 85.801

FSFB02557851 02/01/2013 891.044 867.900 - 23.144

FSFB02554947 02/01/2013 2.451.446 2.365.645 - 85.801

FSFB02557851 02/01/2013 891.044 867.900 - 23.144

FSFB02542034 02/01/2013 1.392.135 1.353.700 - 38.435

FSFB02544595 02/01/2013 587.560 575.809 - 11.751

FSFB02547515 02/01/2013 18.294.395 17.915.473 - 378.922

FSFB02557251 02/01/2013 16.288.744 15.962.795 - 325.949

FSFB02559249 02/01/2013 1.119.992 1.093.728 - 26.264

FSFB02562240 02/01/2013 322.596 287.110 - 35.486

FSFB02562257 02/01/2013 190.364 166.707 - 23.657

FSFB02562766 02/01/2013 215.064 191.407 - 23.657

FSFB02563985 02/01/2013 1.024.122 1.000.978 - 23.144

FSFB02563990 02/01/2013 1.024.122 1.000.978 - 23.144

FSFB02564395 02/01/2013 55.141 49.075 - 6.066

FSFB02537521 02/01/2013 6.877.738 6.625.621 116.900 135.217

FSFB02564395 02/01/2013 55.141 49.075 - 6.066

FSFB02537521 02/01/2013 6.877.738 6.625.621 116.900 135.217

FSFB02537844 02/01/2013 2.734.195 2.229.243 444.983 59.969

FSFB02544036 02/01/2013 2.818.483 2.728.842 32.364 57.277

FSFB02550492 02/01/2013 111.122 98.657 1.400 11.065

FSFB02555100 02/01/2013 1.053.808 1.016.925 - 36.883

FSFB02563463 02/01/2013 993.554 955.849 - 37.705

FSFB02563544 02/01/2013 1.063.368 1.032.837 - 30.531

FSFB02563950 02/01/2013 1.135.835 1.079.176 - 56.659APELACIÓN DE SENTENCIA

009-2018-00099-01 (2398)

FUNDACION SANTA FE DE BOGOTA VS COOMEVA EPS

6

FSFB02564939 02/01/2013 940.668 915.914 - 24.754

FSFB02564941 02/01/2013 1.157.200 1.134.056 - 23.144

FSFB02567584 02/01/2013 215.064 191.407 - 23.657

FSFB02564941 02/01/2013 1.157.200 1.134.056 - 23.144

FSFB02567584 02/01/2013 215.064 191.407 - 23.657

FSFB02533778 02/01/2013 2.455.915 2.399.030 7.925 48.960

FSFB02540764 02/01/2013 4.408.400 4.239.766 82.108 86.526

FSFB02544757 02/01/2013 794.895 759.537 19.857 15.501

FSFB02546364 02/01/2013 1.913.983 1.806.865 56.990 50.128

FSFB02552556 02/01/2013 684.089 660.527 8.432 15.130

FSFB02555667 02/01/2013 4.230.689 4.057.824 82.108 90.757

FSFB02541853 10/01/2013 111.612.489 95.413.440 14.322.581 1.876.468

FSFB02572903 10/01/2013 11.474.493 11.399.623 51.639 23.231

FSFB02508179 10/01/2013 252.089 220.256 8.611 23.222

FSFB02531345 10/01/2013 5.188.803 5.080.423 43.713 64.667

FSFB02533016 10/01/2013 2.319.491 2.095.620 181.103 42.768

FSFB02533016 10/01/2013 2.319.491 2.095.620 181.103 42.768

FSFB02539326 10/01/2013 20.530.509 19.663.668 448.030 418.811

FSFB02547771 10/01/2013 1.187.653 1.065.255 85.574 36.824

FSFB02563539 10/01/2013 1.090.049 1.016.626 35.650 37.773

FSFB02567786 10/01/2013 1.409.094 1.246.590 123.903 38.601

FSFB02526974 10/01/2013 10.144.759 6.873.118 3.076.127 195.514

FSFB02542044 10/01/2013 7.801.141 7.027.804 589.854 183.483

FSFB02555114 10/01/2013 670.681 627.179 30.702 12.800

FSFB02555891 10/01/2013 6.614.876 5.441.386 1.055.129 118.361

FSFB02559246 10/01/2013 1.044.955 999.996 16.839 28.120

FSFB02497444 10/01/2013 1.213.852 1.178.024 3.255 32.573

FSFB02542533 10/01/2013 9.500.405 8.864.798 428.093 207.514

FSFB02547712 10/01/2013 1.037.415 1.006.309 5.935 25.171

FSFB02547712 10/01/2013 1.037.415 1.006.309 5.935 25.171

FSFB02548128 10/01/2013 854.919 826.348 6.863 21.708

FSFB02559083 10/01/2013 173.495 166.634 - 6.861

FSFB02559170 10/01/2013 353.241 278.384 40.178 34.679

FSFB02561989 10/01/2013 786.400 751.904 - 34.496

FSFB02564525 10/01/2013 319.280 288.186 24.953 6.141

FSFB02568076 10/01/2013 19.102.175 18.720.132 - 382.043

FSFB02570018 10/01/2013 298.880 242.563 50.691 5.626

FSFB02570071 10/01/2013 6.852.300 6.715.254 - 137.046

FSFB02570263 10/01/2013 8.406.658 8.112.425 - 294.233

FSFB02570781 10/01/2013 750.119 717.472 - 32.647

FSFB02571319 10/01/2013 1.024.122 1.000.978 - 23.144

FSFB02506469 10/01/2013 921.580 903.148 - 18.432

FSFB02551556 10/01/2013 921.580 903.148 - 18.432

FSFB02506469 10/01/2013 921.580 903.148 - 18.432

FSFB02551556 10/01/2013 921.580 903.148 - 18.432

FSFB02560961 10/01/2013 921.580 903.148 - 18.432

FSFB02571276 10/01/2013 921.580 903.148 - 18.432

FSFB02604736 20/03/2013 54.244.812 49.217.885 3.590.492 1.436.435

FSFB02641695 20/03/2013 5.582.611 5.467.711 - 114.900

FSFB02664938 09/04/2013 23.894 2.294 - 21.600

FSFB02668860 02/05/2013 642.049 228.734 387.345 25.970

FSFB02670668 02/05/2013 168.670 152.163 - 16.507

FSFB02672743 02/05/2013 124.514 112.864 - 11.650

FSFB02672786 02/05/2013 91.955 83.887 - 8.068

FSFB02673342 02/05/2013 71.940 66.074 - 5.866

FSFB02673906 02/05/2013 125.811 120.071 - 5.740APELACIÓN DE SENTENCIA

009-2018-00099-01 (2398)

FUNDACION SANTA FE DE BOGOTA VS COOMEVA EPS

7

009-2018-00099-01 (2398)

FUNDACION SANTA FE DE BOGOTA VS COOMEVA EPS

7

FSFB02673957 02/05/2013 412.218 368.921 - 43.297

FSFB02676496 02/05/2013 223.831 201.257 - 22.574

FSFB02676679 02/05/2013 153.535 138.693 - 14.842

FSFB02677592 02/05/2013 278.931 250.296 - 28.635

FSFB02677710 02/05/2013 82.913 75.840 - 7.073

FSFB02663925 02/05/2013 801.805 715.653 - 86.152

FSFB02650201 02/05/2013 924.701 815.433 8.200 101.068

FSFB02656079 02/05/2013 803.745 651.020 74.562 78.163

FSFB02661847 02/05/2013 1.057.226 937.683 5.950 113.593

FSFB02676750 02/05/2013 748.743 667.034 1.567 80.142

FSFB02677068 02/05/2013 413.248 374.644 1.400 37.204

FSFB02680496 02/05/2013 259.355 229.377 1.628 28.350

FSFB02640299 06/05/2013 921.580 903.148 - 18.432

FSFB02680496 02/05/2013 259.355 229.377 1.628 28.350

FSFB02640299 06/05/2013 921.580 903.148 - 18.432

FSFB02640849 06/05/2013 921.580 903.148 - 18.432

FSFB02655139 06/05/2013 921.580 903.148 - 18.432

FSFB02656839 06/05/2013 921.580 903.148 - 18.432

FSFB02663257 06/05/2013 921.580 903.148 - 18.432

FSFB02678012 06/05/2013 290.280 285.009 - 5.271

FSFB02682838 06/05/2013 1.066.100 1.041.500 - 24.600

FSFB02683918 06/05/2013 435.804 397.696 - 38.108

FSFB02685055 06/05/2013 58.970 42.070 10.922 5.978

FSFB02687780 06/05/2013 1.442.600 659.598 769.541 13.461

FSFB02690661 06/05/2013 623.960 602.121 - 21.839

FSFB02690931 06/05/2013 623.960 602.121 - 21.839

FSFB02715099 05/06/2013 2.970.218 2.926.932 - 43.286

FSFB02728056 07/06/2013 2.185.512 1.970.327 10.909 204.276

FSFB02715099 05/06/2013 2.970.218 2.926.932 - 43.286

FSFB02728056 07/06/2013 2.185.512 1.970.327 10.909 204.276

FSFB02699856 07/06/2013 2.328.480 - - 2.328.480

FSFB02718851 10/07/2013 2.349.164 1.437.603 - 911.561

FSFB02784573 09/08/2013 60.568 26.194 - 34.374

FSFB02773850 09/08/2013 1.994.255 1.941.621 - 52.634

FSFB02755689 13/08/2013 9.994.428 9.868.089 79.258 47.081

FSFB02818807 02/09/2013 6.320.848 1.439.822 - 4.881.026

FSFB02793809 02/09/2013 132.700 - - 132.700

FSFB02812889 02/09/2013 66.144 26.194 - 39.950

FSFB02813846 02/09/2013 23.505 17.650 - 5.855

FSFB02734859 05/09/2013 9.063.126 - 193.694 8.869.432

FSFB02820629 05/09/2013 139.380 115.480 - 23.900

FSFB02831385 11/09/2013 45.105 26.194 - 18.911

FSFB02820629 05/09/2013 139.380 115.480 - 23.900

FSFB02831385 11/09/2013 45.105 26.194 - 18.911

FSFB02831490 11/09/2013 46.689 26.194 - 20.495

FSFB02831960 11/09/2013 33.606 17.892 - 15.714

FSFB02703752 13/09/2013 107.205.545 - 7.379.104 99.826.441

FSFB02842333 13/09/2013 1.115.351 1.081.870 23.917 9.564

FSFB02845432 08/10/2013 34.918.742 29.707.101 95.678 5.115.963

FSFB02854712 08/10/2013 1.900.909 - - 1.900.909

FSFB02839373 08/10/2013 8.309.512 8.045.834 - 263.678

FSFB02798982 08/10/2013 2.279.851 1.272.840 - 1.007.011

FSFB02805911 08/10/2013 1.182.825 - - 1.182.825

FSFB02772883 08/10/2013 13.591.355 - - 13.591.355

FSFB02796827 08/10/2013 20.498.280 - - 20.498.280

FSFB02869743 15/10/2013 581.655 - - 581.655APELACIÓN DE SENTENCIA

009-2018-00099-01 (2398)

FSFB02869743 15/10/2013 581.655 - - 581.655APELACIÓN DE SENTENCIA

009-2018-00099-01 (2398)

FUNDACION SANTA FE DE BOGOTA VS COOMEVA EPS

8

FSFB02883520 01/11/2013 2.358.718 1.051.139 - 1.307.579

FSFB02881800 01/11/2013 1.305.772 1.266.214 34.053 5.505

FSFB02901104 14/11/2013 5.537.600 623.802 - 4.913.798

FSFB02909818 15/11/2013 15.592 9.852 - 5.740

FSFB02730731 15/11/2013 2.546.545 2.452.046 85.399 9.100

FSFB02851532 03/12/2013 49.742.009 - 1.897.691 47.844.318

FSFB02918982 03/12/2013 12.082.601 - 358.855 11.723.746

FSFB02927466 04/12/2013 31.707 26.194 - 5.513

FSFB02931315 09/12/2013 15.714 10.210 - 5.504

FSFB02925053 10/12/2013 1.976.518 1.922.078 - 54.440

FSFB02874777 10/12/2013 12.990.938 - 411.078 12.579.860

FSFB02883481 10/12/2013 15.263.524 14.938.864 - 324.660

FSFB02874777 10/12/2013 12.990.938 - 411.078 12.579.860

FSFB02883481 10/12/2013 15.263.524 14.938.864 - 324.660

FSFB02895269 10/12/2013 23.019.234 - 638.693 22.380.541

FSFB02939783 02/01/2014 22.175.370 21.474.567 - 700.803

FSFB02953307 02/01/2014 90.271.286 88.812.338 - 1.458.948

FSFB02953311 02/01/2014 90.271.286 87.346.372 - 2.924.914

FSFB02948283 02/01/2014 111.584 104.850 - 6.734

FSFB02952554 03/01/2014 81.547 - - 81.547

FSFB02954084 07/01/2014 4.273.642 3.875.933 9.964 387.745

FSFB02950083 10/01/2014 6.434.366 6.230.693 27.273 176.400

FSFB02961339 10/01/2014 193.772 186.548 - 7.224

FSFB02959247 10/01/2014 38.052 14.258 - 23.794

FSFB02964137 15/01/2014 39.907 30.407 - 9.500

FSFB02964247 15/01/2014 261.879 255.822 - 6.057

FSFB02964137 15/01/2014 39.907 30.407 - 9.500

FSFB02964247 15/01/2014 261.879 255.822 - 6.057

FSFB02964563 15/01/2014 794.808 771.697 - 23.111

FSFB02968508 03/02/2014 401.245 390.728 - 10.517

FSFB02968670 03/02/2014 524.647 517.054 - 7.593

FSFB02974788 03/02/2014 346.901 338.123 - 8.778

FSFB02974821 03/02/2014 10.038.670 9.719.756 - 318.914

FSFB02976236 03/02/2014 260.974 254.946 - 6.028

FSFB02967239 03/02/2014 4.335.136 4.198.735 - 136.401

FSFB02972464 03/02/2014 344.766 336.057 - 8.709

FSFB02973713 03/02/2014 387.395 377.322 - 10.073

FSFB02973758 03/02/2014 519.131 504.842 - 14.289

FSFB02975872 03/02/2014 1.835.721 1.798.946 - 36.775

FSFB02976198 03/02/2014 4.652.634 4.527.950 - 124.684

FSFB02979485 03/02/2014 1.726.844 1.680.781 - 46.063

FSFB02976198 03/02/2014 4.652.634 4.527.950 - 124.684

FSFB02979485 03/02/2014 1.726.844 1.680.781 - 46.063

FSFB02979558 03/02/2014 562.949 547.258 - 15.691

FSFB02980069 03/02/2014 953.000 946.078 - 6.922

FSFB02690265 03/02/2014 5.082.329 4.864.217 - 218.112

FSFB02919988 03/02/2014 709.476 684.912 664 23.900

FSFB02933503 03/02/2014 699.348 679.195 - 20.153

FSFB02946670 03/02/2014 82.903 - - 82.903

FSFB02752422 03/02/2014 1.852.243 1.816.106 - 36.137

FSFB02981498 04/02/2014 509.294 495.320 - 13.974

FSFB02982804 04/02/2014 743.106 721.650 - 21.456

FSFB02984445 04/02/2014 266.889 260.672 - 6.217

FSFB02978324 07/02/2014 1.675.951 922.289 - 753.662

FSFB02989843 07/02/2014 554.022 538.616 - 15.406

FSFB02983983 07/02/2014 369.483 363.936 - 5.547APELACIÓN DE SENTENCIA

FSFB02989843 07/02/2014 554.022 538.616 - 15.406

FSFB02983983 07/02/2014 369.483 363.936 - 5.547APELACIÓN DE SENTENCIA

009-2018-00099-01 (2398)

FUNDACION SANTA FE DE BOGOTA VS COOMEVA EPS

9

FSFB02984353 07/02/2014 644.788 626.478 - 18.310

FSFB02991331 07/02/2014 229.186 224.175 - 5.011

FSFB02990571 10/02/2014 225.992 - - 225.992

FSFB02954660 10/02/2014 25.058.537 24.846.758 54.546 157.233

FSFB02981033 10/02/2014 18.226.256 2.034.427 388.470 15.803.359

FSFB02767526 10/02/2014 6.479.538 - 492.555 5.986.983

FSFB02959175 10/02/2014 3.015.830 1.145.371 49.465 1.820.994

FSFB02973469 10/02/2014 4.160.439 - - 4.160.439

FSFB02980297 10/02/2014 724.432 710.446 - 13.986

FSFB02980344 10/02/2014 1.093.942 1.061.259 - 32.683

FSFB02983177 10/02/2014 2.937.766 - 598.308 2.339.458

FSFB02980344 10/02/2014 1.093.942 1.061.259 - 32.683

FSFB02983177 10/02/2014 2.937.766 - 598.308 2.339.458

FSFB02984311 10/02/2014 44.403.599 - 721.046 43.682.553

FSFB02993906 14/02/2014 2.240.143 2.177.654 - 62.489

FSFB02994190 14/02/2014 344.621 335.916 - 8.705

FSFB02997899 14/02/2014 583.602 567.250 - 16.352

FSFB02999429 03/03/2014 1.538.435 1.522.146 - 16.289

FSFB03000085 03/03/2014 4.133.503 4.048.603 - 84.900

FSFB03006010 03/03/2014 4.416.949 2.550.380 12.442 1.854.127

FSFB03008744 03/03/2014 38.100 - - 38.100

FSFB02980646 03/03/2014 1.266.900 1.248.470 - 18.430

FSFB02994666 03/03/2014 8.499.210 1.407.700 - 7.091.510

FSFB02996591 03/03/2014 3.811.479 1.601.610 - 2.209.869

FSFB03007147 03/03/2014 43.270 - - 43.270

FSFB02996591 03/03/2014 3.811.479 1.601.610 - 2.209.869

FSFB03007147 03/03/2014 43.270 - - 43.270

FSFB03016055 03/03/2014 538.585 - 15.346 523.239

FSFB03012652 03/03/2014 1.071.910 1.044.229 - 27.681

FSFB03014348 07/03/2014 11.004.658 10.582.258 - 422.400

FSFB03017227 07/03/2014 911.607 - - 911.607

FSFB03017935 07/03/2014 9.914.904 9.565.104 - 349.800

FSFB03022582 07/03/2014 35.755 - - 35.755

FSFB03005650 10/03/2014 50.826.331 - 1.420.430 49.405.901

FSFB03011203 10/03/2014 12.135.093 10.618.829 222.837 1.293.427

FSFB03016419 10/03/2014 51.696.012 - - 443.562

FSFB03016667 10/03/2014 90.502.403 64.382.965 238.108 25.881.330

FSFB02592752 10/03/2014 7.458.880 - 651.705 6.807.175

FSFB02713806 10/03/2014 2.661.404 146.718 23.900 2.490.786

FSFB02592752 10/03/2014 7.458.880 - 651.705 6.807.175

FSFB02713806 10/03/2014 2.661.404 146.718 23.900 2.490.786

FSFB02733071 10/03/2014 3.928.333 - - 3.928.333

FSFB02760547 10/03/2014 1.319.648 - - 1.319.648

FSFB02771663 10/03/2014 24.384.800 9.296.576 2.300 15.085.924

FSFB02779916 10/03/2014 340.522 - - 340.522

FSFB02836124 10/03/2014 472.399 - - 472.399

FSFB02920878 10/03/2014 2.093.430 2.031.556 - 61.874

FSFB03024648 01/04/2014 8.804.310 8.474.310 - 330.000

FSFB03027833 01/04/2014 9.914.904 9.515.304 2.788 396.812

FSFB03035918 01/04/2014 705.904 - 13.050 692.854

FSFB03030817 01/04/2014 886.487 870.022 - 16.465

FSFB03034178 01/04/2014 170.755 148.227 - 22.528

FSFB03034882 01/04/2014 181.390 - - 181.390

FSFB03044126 01/04/2014 105.136 - - 105.136

FSFB03034882 01/04/2014 181.390 - - 181.390

FSFB03044126 01/04/2014 105.136 - - 105.136

FSFB03037220 01/04/2014 520.147 - - 520.147

FSFB03031398 01/04/2014 3.961.479 3.766.995 - 194.484APELACIÓN DE SENTENCIA

009-2018-00099-01 (2398)

FUNDACION SANTA FE DE BOGOTA VS COOMEVA EPS

10

FSFB03045027 01/04/2014 4.704.764 4.603.886 724 100.154

FSFB03047624 01/04/2014 299.210 290.832 - 8.378

FSFB03054401 07/04/2014 20.927.100 - - 20.927.100

FSFB03044759 09/04/2014 1.592.858 1.235.860 - 356.998

FSFB03045213 09/04/2014 7.182.085 - - 7.182.085

FSFB03000117 09/04/2014 5.284.475 5.136.510 - 147.965

FSFB03008503 09/04/2014 42.198.994 988.254 6.395.099 34.815.641

FSFB03012604 09/04/2014 37.568.470 2.389.533 2.779.777 550.246

FSFB03037793 09/04/2014 584.510 501.010 - 83.500

FSFB03012604 09/04/2014 37.568.470 2.389.533 2.779.777 550.246

FSFB03037793 09/04/2014 584.510 501.010 - 83.500

FSFB03043581 10/04/2014 51.702.492 - 5.090.940 826.144

FSFB03050166 10/04/2014 53.737.681 4.435.133 824.139 48.478.409

FSFB03050301 10/04/2014 48.063.849 - - 48.063.849

FSFB03050968 10/04/2014 48.213.423 - - 48.213.423

FSFB03011171 10/04/2014 58.236.147 6.254.896 - 51.981.251

FSFB03030661 10/04/2014 1.160.000 - - 1.160.000

FSFB03048644 10/04/2014 11.287.360 - - 11.287.360

FSFB03057105 10/04/2014 33.124 - - 33.124

FSFB03061622 10/04/2014 8.949.210 8.474.310 697 474.203

FSFB02996196 10/04/2014 45.302.981 - - 45.302.981

FSFB03032316 10/04/2014 8.960.244 - 75.000 8.885.244

FSFB03037622 10/04/2014 10.452.074 - 170.584 10.281.490

FSFB03032316 10/04/2014 8.960.244 - 75.000 8.885.244

FSFB03037622 10/04/2014 10.452.074 - 170.584 10.281.490

FSFB03047886 10/04/2014 5.575.930 37.957 184.352 5.353.621

FSFB03049405 10/04/2014 2.209.704 1.932.501 9.419 267.784

FSFB03048269 15/04/2014 7.860.470 - - 7.860.470

FSFB03065661 15/04/2014 3.534.176 1.650.313 51.224 1.832.639

FSFB03066378 15/04/2014 27.387 9.720 280 17.387

FSFB03052321 15/04/2014 3.348.278 - 461.245 2.887.033

FSFB03065954 02/05/2014 1.261.160 - - 1.261.160

FSFB03075915 02/05/2014 68.401 - - 68.401

FSFB03076502 02/05/2014 1.242.586 1.014.844 - 227.742

FSFB03081941 02/05/2014 1.791.614 - - 1.791.614

FSFB03088962 07/05/2014 222.948 214.841 - 8.107

FSFB03051010 09/05/2014 1.974.021 780.602 30.223 1.163.196

FSFB03088962 07/05/2014 222.948 214.841 - 8.107

FSFB03051010 09/05/2014 1.974.021 780.602 30.223 1.163.196

FSFB03063580 09/05/2014 14.793.697 14.024.284 - 769.413

TOTAL $ 871.222.944

Se expresa que vencido el término legal para la presentación de glosas u objeciones a las relaciones de cobro y facturas antes mencionadas, COOMEVA no manifestó inconformidad alguna en cuanto a su valor, pertinencia o calidad de afiliados de las personas atendidas, ni realizó el pago conforme a lo dispuesto en los Art.13 de la ley 1122 de 2007 y 56 de la ley 1438 de 2011 ; fuera del término legal , hizo algunos pagos que fueron abonados a cada una de las facturas como se indicó en el cuadro anterior.

La mora en el pago de las sumas de dinero representadas en las relaciones de cobro y factur